Wind catches
the yellow sail
of the tulip
Wind catches the yellow sail of the tulip |
Daily DeviationGiven 2008-08-31For me, a haiku must be simple, yet visual and evocative. Yellow haiku by *diamondie is all this and more. (Featured by `lovetodeviate) Comments
Hmm? I haven't said anything about using a 3-5-3 rule in this piece. Generally when I write haiku the only rule about syllables I pay attention is the piece being under 5-7-5 or less (usually less, because 5-7-5 has started to feel far too verbose to me!), but I once wrote a haiku conferring to an arbitrary 3-5-3 rule, because it was for a contest.
But glad you liked it nonetheless. :-> -- What do death, Chinese checkers and My CFS/ME/FM treatment book Beautiful.
-- oh hai. { gallery. | portfolio. } Wow - I used to hope I'd get a DD one day and now I really don't. People are so dumb. Anyway - I've already faved this but I had a suggestion. The repetition of "the" I feel is a little clumsy and unnecessary. I feel that repeating a word like "the" in the poem makes the "the" dominate the poem too much. It could easily be remedied by replacing the second one with an "a" like so;
wind catches the yellow sail of a tulip I would also remove the capital so as not to give any one word prominence in the piece. Lovely poem!!!!!!!! I hope you don't mind me replying to some of the idiots who have left comments. I mean - for crying out loud, anyone would think they were haiku experts or something. I love this work! -- "We are intent on reducing art to its simplest expression, which is love." (Andre Breton) You have a good point there about the article, I just feel like it emphasizes the singular nature of the tulip too much. For me "the" makes it one tulip in focus among a bunch of tulips (they rarely grow alone, after all), while "a" creates an image of a single tulip. But I'm not a native speaker, so someone else might see it in a different way, even the opposite.
Thanks a lot, and I don't mind at all. I'm just afraid you're wasting your time trying to educate people. -- What do death, Chinese checkers and My CFS/ME/FM treatment book Right - I can see what you mean but I am not sure that it necessarily gives that impression. In fact, for me it is the other way around. When I think of "the tulip" I tend to think of a tulip on its own with no others around - ie. it is "the" tulip. But when I hear "a tulip" in this poem I feel more like it is one of many. And for me I guess the repetition of the word "the" is overbearing in the poem, taking focus away from the image.
All the best- Dick from Solar -- "We are intent on reducing art to its simplest expression, which is love." (Andre Breton) You have a good point there about the article, I just feel like it emphasizes the singular nature of the tulip too much. For me "the" makes it one tulip in focus among a bunch of tulips (they rarely grow alone, after all), while "a" creates an image of a single tulip. But I'm not a native speaker, so someone else might see it in a different way, even the opposite.
Thanks a lot, and I don't mind at all. I'm just afraid you're wasting your time trying to educate people. -- What do death, Chinese checkers and My CFS/ME/FM treatment book You have a good point there about the article, I just feel like it emphasizes the singular nature of the tulip too much. For me "the" makes it one tulip in focus among a bunch of tulips (they rarely grow alone, after all), while "a" creates an image of a single tulip. But I'm not a native speaker, so someone else might see it in a different way, even the opposite.
Thanks a lot, and I don't mind at all. I'm just afraid you're wasting your time trying to educate people. -- What do death, Chinese checkers and My CFS/ME/FM treatment book You have a good point there about the article, I just feel like it emphasizes the singular nature of the tulip too much. For me "the" makes it one tulip in focus among a bunch of tulips (they rarely grow alone, after all), while "a" creates an image of a single tulip. But I'm not a native speaker, so someone else might see it in a different way, even the opposite.
Thanks a lot, and I don't mind at all. I'm just afraid you're wasting your time trying to educate people. -- What do death, Chinese checkers and My CFS/ME/FM treatment book |
Found in these Groups:Not currently found in a Group
Details
July 20, 2008
142 bytes Statistics |
Critiques
Thank you for your Critique
You are not logged in.